Adventures in Marriage and Polyamory

'Free Love' by Michelle Tea.

SEX TALK

Adventures in Marriage and Polyamory

From my weepy Zoom therapy perch, I pondered the thorniness and frailty of women’s sexual freedom. Is something wrong with me, for wanting it? My desire for an open relationship is really a desire for so many things, and some of those things are sexual experiences with men I don’t know, experiences that render me submissive, that push up against the shadowy spheres of my sexuality. Am I self-destructive? Is my craving for sex with strangers nothing but the expression of the famed death drive rearing up inside my psyche? Is it an addiction? Am I delusional, ruined from reading too many Anaïs Nin journals in my teens? From watching Madonna’s “Justify My Love” video over and over in my early twenties? Should I blame art for my erotic discontent?

The answer may well be yes; literature and cinema are tumescent with aspirational scenes of sexual freedom. I recall leaving a screening of Poor Things with a strange sense of grief in my heart, that I would never get to be Bella Baxter (and it wasn’t just her poufy-sleeved ensembles I coveted). While the character’s greedy sexuality struck many in my world as the most grotesque of male fantasies—an easy-to-fuck baby-woman!—I luxuriated in the vision of a sexually hungry woman utterly untouched by sexual shame. While this may have resonated with many a horny cis dude, it was my fantasy, too.

Reading an advance copy of Miranda July’s novel All Fours on my couch with my morning coffee, I burst into tears at its denouement, which suggests that the repressed sexual power of females is the skeleton in history’s closet. I felt a piece of myself in that closet, brittle and skinless and hidden. I chased that book with the only novel that could not disappoint in the wake of such a resonant story, the brilliant Nightbitch by Rachel Yoder. More otherworldly than July’s tale of a plausible (if elevated and creative) extramarital affair by a mom tipping on the psychedelia of perimenopause, Nightbitch also concerns a mom, one who satisfies her own longing for more by transforming into a dog and galloping through the city at night, delighting in crushing small, furred mammals in her powerful jaws, exulting in the coppery tang of blood spilled. Delicious.

‘Free Love’ by Michelle Tea.

I’m obviously not alone in my desires. Nightbitch doesn’t make a statement about the way monogamy deadens a woman’s spirit per se, but those passages of the narrator running wild in canine form strike me as deeply carnal, tapping into a collective female yearning for access to our wildest potential. All Fours winds down with the narrator and her husband gingerly exploring an open marriage. Elsewhere in media, interest in polyamory continues, unabated. Buzzy books detail the extracurricular trysts of middle-class, hetero moms. A full issue of New York Magazine is devoted to the phenomenon. On an episode of the internet-hoax reality show Catfish, a shady influencer cops to having lied about being in an open relationship; it’s so hot to be seen as poly right now that it’s good for her brand.

You either love it or you hate it, this moment that polyamory is having. You might love it if your throuple has been looking for some fuck, yes! validation from the parent culture. Or, if you’re in need of some literature to leave around the house, hoping to spark a conversation with your spouse about opening up. Haters are going to hate, I suppose. Though I remain shocked by how many people continue to clutch pearls at the perceived transgressions of polyamory, some of the back-lash today comes from sensible people tired of hearing poly people yammer on about their ’cule.

Excerpt from Free Love. Reprinted with the permission of the publisher HarperOne, an imprint of HarperCollins. Copyright © 2026 by Michelle Tea.