There’s a moment in season four of NBC’s Emmy-winning competition show The Traitors that made me realize I was, in fact, a Rob Rausch fan. At the end of the second episode, the sexy snake wrangler slash Love Island USA alum and his fellow Traitors Candiace Dillard Bassett and Lisa Rinna must commit a murder in plain sight. While Dillard Bassett distracts the Faithfuls with an impromptu conga line, Rausch retrieves the tarot cards hidden behind a painting in the kitchen, shoves them into the front pocket of his jeans, and whispers a victorious “fuck yeah” to himself before joining Rinna over a game of chess to subtly select their victim.
“You like that?” Rausch asks Rinna after they finish strategizing. And from that moment on, I couldn’t stop rooting for him as he lied, schemed, and double-crossed his way to victory, walking away with a little over $200,000.
But the 28-year-old Alabama native never saw himself becoming a reality TV star, let alone one of America’s biggest (and most mysterious) heartthrobs. For someone whose idea of a good time is relaxing in the two-bedroom trailer he calls home (which, crucially, has no television or internet) in the peaceful countryside where he grew up, playing Settlers of Catan and working on Creek Rat, the clothing brand he started with his sister, the spotlight can sometimes feel overwhelming.
“I’m an introvert. I can be extroverted, but I need to be alone to recharge my battery and really process how I feel,” he told Interview earlier this year. “My only aspiration is to be happy, and that doesn’t mean being on television.”
Before making his reality TV debut as a bombshell in Casa Amor on Day 16 of season five of Love Island USA, Rausch was working as a snake-removal specialist, posting videos of himself confidently snatching reptiles from creeks and jungles in nothing but a pair of swim shorts and boots. He quickly discovered that the world of reality TV was far more treacherous than any snake-infested forest, getting dumped on Day 21. He’d return for season six, where he’d become one of the dating show’s most controversial contestants thanks to his short-lived and turbulent connection with Leah Kateb.
“I definitely didn’t handle things as well as I could’ve and I did my best to rectify it, take accountability for it, and forgive myself for it,” he said, reflecting on his season. “Because I’m hard on myself. It’s one of my character traits, and I can get real down if I let myself feed into negativity like that. But then I move on and learn from it. It’s been a learning experience overall.”

Rob Rausch • Photo: MediaPunch.
He’d redeem himself a year and a half later on The Traitors, though at first, he wasn’t sure if he wanted to be on reality TV again.
“I said no twice,” Rob told E! News about being cast. “[B]ut I love games and I love competing. I have never watched any reality [TV] other than Survivor, and I thought this was kind of a similar vibe.”
All of the qualities that made Rausch an antagonist on Love Island USA were the ones that would make him an excellent Traitor–and by extension, give him a shot at rewriting his reputation.
“I’ve been underestimated my entire life,” he says in his confessional after Michael Rapaport comes at him for his quiet demeanor and “nice good looks” in episode one. “I’m kind of quiet, but I think that’s one of my biggest strengths. When people underestimate you, that’s when you catch them by surprise.”
As much as his fellow contestants insist that it was those very “nice good looks” that helped him win (at one point Johnny Weir mentions that he’s “so hot, I can’t even look at him”), both Rausch and diehard fans of the show know that’s not the whole story.
Maybe that’s what we mean when we talk about “aura,” the internet’s catch-all term for the kind of magnetism that can’t quite be explained by physical appearance alone. Rausch has the looks, obviously–who else could make a pair of overalls look that good that effortlessly?–but it’s the contrast between his obvious, Abercrombie & Fitch appeal and his unassuming nature that makes him so compelling. He’s not a himbo, far from that. He can outsmart an entire castle full of Survivor veterans. He’s not afraid to put Rapaport in his place (“Commiseration means to feel sorry for someone!” he tells the comedian in one of the season’s most talked about moments). He’s remarkably humble about and grateful for the opportunities that have come his way, even if wants to, as he told GQ in February, “do more stuff that has nothing to do with me at all.”
This fall, Peacock announced that he and fellow Traitors alum Maura Higgins–whom he double-crossed in the season finale–will be reuniting to host Get Me Out of Here, an updated version of I’m a Celebrity…Get Me Out of Here!, set to premiere in 2027. And as much as I’d like for this sensitive snake wrangler to retire to the swamp for good, like he wants to, I’m happy he’ll be returning to TV. After all, a man like that deserves to be seen on a screen bigger than my phone.
Instagram: @robert_rausch


